Notes Repository (AUSL 2002-2006; Haystacks)

It was during the second year of my law school studies (SY 2003-2004) that I started to create a new format for my case notes, since I observed that some cases in the previous year were reiterated in the higher subjects. Resort to previously made digests was inappropriate, since the issues focused were different. I created these notes, which I called “Haystacks,” to outline all legal details provided in the cases’ discussions, to serve as source documents when I would need to create case digests, appropriate to the issues relevant to the subjects in which the cases could be reiterated anew.

Haystacks

Haystacks for Property try to cover the following cases: 1) Agne v. Director of Lands [GR No. 40399. February 6, 1990.]; (2) Ago v. CA [GR No. L-17898. October 31, 1962.]; (3) Agustin v. IAC [GR Nos. 66075-76. July 5, 1990.]; (4) Antipolo v. Zapanta [GR No. 65334. December 26, 1984.]; (5) Assistant Secretary for Legal Affairs v. CA [GR No. 76761. January 9, 1989.]; (6) Associated Insurance & Surety v. Iya [GR Nos. L-10837-38. May 30, 1958.]; (7) Bachrach v. Seifert [GR No. L-2659. October 12, 1950.]; (8) Bachrach Motors v. Talisay-Silay Milling [GR No. 35223. September 17, 1931.]; (9) Baes v. CA [GR No. 108065. July 6, 1993.]; (10) Baltazar v. Caridad [GR No. L-23509. June 23, 1966.]; (11) Balucanag v. Francisco [GR No. L-33422. May 30, 1983.]; (12) Bataclan v. CFI Cavite [GR No. 43456. May 6, 1935.]; (13) Bautista v. Alarcon [GR No. 8153. December 24, 1912.]; (14) Berkenkotter v. Cu Unjieng [GR No. 41643. July 31, 1935.]; (15) Bicerra v. Teneza [GR No. L-16218. November 29, 1962.]; (16) Binalay v. Manalo [GR No. 92161. March 18, 1991.]; (17) Board of Assessment Appeals v. City Treasurer [GR No. L-15334. January 31, 1964.]; (18) Burgos v. Chief of Staff, AFP [GR No. 64261. December 26, 1984.]; (19) Municipality of Cavite v. Rojas [GR No. 9069. March 31, 1915.]; (20) Cebu Oxygen & Acetylene v. Bercilles [GR No. L-40474. August 29, 1975.]; (21) Chua v. CA [GR No. 109840. January 21, 1999.]; (22) Chua Guan v. Samahang Magsasaka [GR No. 42091. November 2, 1935.]; (23) Chua Peng Hian v. CA [GR No. 60015. December 19, 1984.]; (24) Cureg v. IAC [GR No. 73465. September 7, 1989.]; (25) Dacanay v. Asistio [GR No. 93654. May 6, 1992.]; (26) Davao Sawmill v. Castillo [GR No. 40411. August 7, 1935.]; (27) De Buyser v. Director of Lands [GR No. L-22763. March 18, 1983.]; (28) De Guzman v. dela Fuente [GR No. 32433. December 29, 1930.]; (29) Del Campo v. Fernandez-Abesia [GR No. L-49219. April 15, 1988.]; (30) Depra v. Dumlao [GR No. L-57348. May 16, 1985.]; (31) Director of Forestry v. Villareal [GR No. L-32266. February 27, 1989.]; (32) Director of Lands v. CA [GR No. 58867. June 22, 1984.]; (33) Director of Lands v. IAC [GR No. 73246. March 2, 1993.]; (34) Espiritu v. Municipal Council of Pozorrubio, Pangasinan [GR No. L-11014. January 21, 1958.]; (35) Evangelista v. Alto Surety [GR No. L-11139. April 23, 1958.]; (36) Ferrer vs. Bautista [GR No. 46963. March 14, 1994.]; (37) Geminiano v. CA [GR No. 120303. July 24, 1996.]; (38) German Management & Services v. CA (Gernale, Villeza) [GR No. 76216 and 76217. September 14, 1989.]; (39) Grande v. CA [GR No. L-17652. June 30, 1962.]; (40) GSIS v. Calson [GR No. L-19867. May 29, 1968.]; (41) Government v. Cabangis [GR No. 28379. March 27, 1929.]; (42) Government v. Colegio de San Jose [GR No. 30829. August 28, 1929.]; (43) Grana v. CA [GR No. L-12486. August 31, 1960.]; (44) Harty v. Victoria, Tarlac [GR No. 5013. March 11, 1909.]; (45) Hilario v. City of Manila [GR No. L-19570 April 27, 1967]; (46) Hinunangan (Municipality of) v. Director of Lands [GR No. 7054. January 20, 1913.]; (47) Hodges v. Garcia [GR No. L-12730. August 22, 1960.]; (48) Hongkong & Shanghai Banking v. Aldecoa & Co. [GR No. 8437. March 23, 1915.]; (49) Ignacio v. Director of Lands [GR No. L-12958. May 30, 1960.]; (50) Ignacio v. Hilario [GR No. L-175. April 30, 1946.]; (51) Ignao v. IAC [GR No. 72876. January 18, 1991.]; (52) Inter-regional Development Corporation v. CA [GR No. L-39677. July 22, 1975.]; (53) Jacinto v. Director of Lands [GR No. 26374. December 31, 1926.]; (54) Jagualing v. CA [GR No. 94283. March 4, 1991.]; (55) Laurel v. Garcia [GR No. 92013 & 92047. July 25, 1990.]; (56) Leung Yee v. Strong Machinery [GR No. L-11658. February 15, 1918.]; (57) Lopez v. Orosa [GR Nos. L-10817-18. February 28, 1958.]; (58) Macasiano v. Diokno [GR No. 97764. August 10, 1992.]; (59) Makati Leasing v. Wearever Textiles [GR No. L-58469. May 16, 1983.]; (60) Manalo v. IAC [GR No. 64753. April 26, 1989.]; (61) Manarang v. Ofilada [GR No. L-8133. May 18, 1956.]; (62) Maneclang v. IAC [GR No. L-66575. September 30, 1986.]; (63) Manila Lodge 761 v. CA [GR No. L-41001. September 30, 1976.]; (64) Manotok Realty v. Tecson [GR No. L-47475. August 19, 1988.]; (65) Mapa v. Insular Government [GR No. L-3793. February 19, 1908.]; (66) Mercado v. CA [GR No. L-44001. June 10, 1988.]; (67) Mercado v. Municipal President of Macabebe [GR No. 37986. March 1, 1934.]; (68) Mindanao Bus v. City Assessor [GR No. L-17870. September 29, 1962.]; (69) Miranda v. Fadullon [GR No. L-8220. October 29, 1955.]; (70) Monserrat v. Ceron [GR No. 37078. September 27, 1933.]; (71) MWSS v. CA [GR No. L-54526. August 25, 1986.]; (72) Navarro v. Pineda [GR No. L-18456. November 30, 1963.]; (73) Oas (Municipality of) v. Roa [GR No. L-2017. November 24, 1906.; (74) Pacific Farms v. Esguerra [GR No. L-21783. November 29, 1969.]; (75) Panlilio v. Mercado [GR No. 18771. March 26, 1923.]; (76) Pecson v. CA [GR No. 115814. May 26, 1995.]; (77) People’s Bank v. Dahican Lumber [GR No. L-17500. May 16, 1967.]; (78) Philippine Refining v. Jarque [GR No. 41506. March 25, 1935.]; (79) Piansay v. David [GR No. L-19468. October 30, 1964.]; (80) Pleasantville Development v. CA [GR No. 79688. February 1, 1996.]; (81) Prudential Bank v. Panis [GR No. L-50008. August 31, 1987.]; (82) Punsalan v. vda. De Lacsamana [GR No. L-55729. March 28, 1983.]; (83) Quemuel v. Olaes [GR No. L-11084. April 29, 1961.]; (84) Republic v. Alagad [GR No. 66807. January 26, 1989.]; (85) Republic v. CA [GR No. L-43105. August 31, 1984.]; (86) Republic v. CA [GR No. L-61647. October 12, 1984.]; (87) Republic v. IAC [GR No. 73085. June 4, 1990.]; (88) Reynante v. CA [GR No. 95907. April 8, 1992.]; (89) Ronquillo v. CA [GR No. 43346. March 20, 1991.]; (90) Roxas v. Tuason [GR No. L-3788. December 21, 1907.]; (91) Rubiso vs. Rivera [GR L-11407, 30 October 1917]; (92) San Diego v. Montesa [GR No. L-17985. September 29, 1962.]; (93) Santos v. Mojica [GR No. L-25450. January 31, 1969.]; (94) Santos v. Moreno [GR No. L-15829. December 4, 1967.]; (95) Sarmiento v. Agana [GR No. 57288. April 30, 1984.]; (96) Serg’s Products v. PCI Leasing [GR No. 137705. August 22, 2000.]; (97) Sibal v. Valdez [GR No. 26278. August 4, 1927.]; (98) Standard Oil v. Jaramillo [GR No. 20329. March 16, 1923.]; (99) Involuntary insolvency of Paul Strochecker v. Ramirez [GR No. 18700. September 26, 1922.]; (100) Tan Queto v. CA [GR No. L-35648. February 27, 1987.]; Resolution; (101) Tumalad v. Vicencio [GR No. L-30173. September 30, 1971.]; (102) US v. Carlos [GR No. 6295. September 1, 1911.]; (103) US v. Tambunting [GR No. 16513. January 18, 1921.]; (104) Vda. De Nazareno v. CA [GR No. 98045. June 26, 1996.]; (105) Vda. De Tantoco v. Muncipal Council of Iloilo [GR No. 24950. March 25, 1926.]; (106) Viajar v. CA [GR No. 77294. December 12, 1988.]; (107) Villanueva v. Castaneda [GR No. L-61311. September 21, 1987.]; (108) Province of Zamboanga del Norte v. City of Zamboanga [GR No. L-24440. March 28, 1968.]

Haystacks for Administrative Law try to cover the following cases: (1) Ang Tibay v. CIR [GR 46496, 27 February 1940]; (2) Carino vs. CHR [GR 96681, 2 December 1991]; (3) CSC vs. Lucas [GR 127838, 21 January 1999]; (4) Corona vs. United Harbor Pilots Association of the Philippines [GR 111953, 12 December 1997]; (5) Cruz vs. Youngberg [GR 34674. 26 October 1931]; (6) Gonzales vs. LBP [GR 76759, 22 March 1990]; (7) Guevara vs. Comelec [GR L-12596, 31 July 1958]; (8) Land Bank vs. CA [GR 118712, 6 October 1995]; (9) Masangcay vs. Comelec [GR L-13827, 28 September 1962]; (10) Ocampo vs. Ombudsman [GR 114683, 18 January 2000]; (11) Padilla vs. Sto. Tomas [GR 109444, 31 March 1995]; (12) RCPI vs. NTC [GR 66683, 23 April 1990]; (13) Suntay v. People [GR L-9430, 29 June 1957]; (14) Tolentino vs. SSC [GR L-28870, 6 September 1985]

Haystacks for Sales try to cover the following cases: (1) Acap vs. CA [GR 118114, 7 December 1995]; (2) Adalin vs. CA [GR 120191, 10 October 1997]; (3) Addison vs. Felix [GR 12342, 3 August 1918]; (4) Adelfa Properties vs. CA [GR 111238, 25 January 1995]; (5) Agricultural and Home Extension Development Group vs. CA [GR 92310, 3 September 1992]; (6) Almendra vs. IAC [GR 75111, 21 November 1991]; (7) Ang Yu Asuncion, et.al, vs. CA [GR 109125, 2 December 1994]; (8) Angeles vs. Calasanz [GR L-42283, 18 March 1985]; (9) Azcona vs. Reyes [GR 39590, 6 February 1934]; (10) Aznar vs. Yapdiangco [GR L-18536, 31 March 1965]; (11) Babasa vs. CA [GR 124045, 21 May 1998]; (12) Bagnas vs. CA [GR 38498, 10 August 1989]; (13) Balatbat vs. CA [GR 109410, 28 August 1996]; (14) Calimlim-Canullas vs. Fortun [GR 57499, 22 June 1984]; (15) Carbonell vs. CA [GR L-29972, 26 January 1976]; (16) Carumba vs. CA [GR L-27587, 18 February 1970]; (17) Celestino Co vs. Collector of Internal Revenue [GR L-8506, 31 August 1956]; (18) Cheng vs. Genato [GR 129760, 29 December 1998]; (19) CIR vs. Engineering Equipment and Supply [GR L-27044, 30 June 1975]; (20) Coronel vs. CA [GR 103577, 7 October 1996]; (21) Coronel vs. Ona [GR 10280, 7 February 1916]; (22) Cruz vs. Cabana [GR 56232, 22 June 1984]; (23) Cruz vs. Filipinas Investment [GR L-24772, 27 May 1968]; (24) Dagupan Trading vs. Macam [GR L-18497, 31 May 1965]; (25) Dalion vs. CA [GR 78903, 28 February 1990]; (26) Daguilan vs. IAC [GR L-69970, 28 November 1988]; (27) De la Cavada vs. Diaz [GR L-11668, 1 April 1918]; (28) Delta Motors Sales vs. Niu Kim Duan [GR 61043, 2 September 1992]; (29) Dignos vs. Lumungsod [GR L-59266, 29 February 1988]; (30) Doromal vs. CA [GR L-36083, 5 September 1975]; (31) Dy vs. CA [GR 92989, 8 July 1991]; (32) EDCA Publishing vs. Santos [GR 80298, 26 April 1990]; (33) Engineering and Machinery Corp. vs. CA [GR 52267, 24 January 1996]; (34) Equatorial Realty vs. Mayfair Theater [GR 106063, 21 November 1996]; (35) Intestate Estate of Emilio Camon; Ereneta vs. Bezore [GR L-29746, 26 November 1973]; (36) Heirs of Escanlar, et.al, vs. CA [GR 119777, 23 October 1997]; (37) Espiritu vs. Valerio [GR L-18018, 26 December 1963]; (38) Estoque vs. Pajimula [GR L-24419, 15 July 1968]; (39) Filinvest Credit vs. CA [GR 82508, 29 September 1989]; (40) Filipinas Investment vs. Ridad [GR L-27645, 28 November 1969]; (41) Fule vs. CA [GR 112212, 2 March 1998]; (42) Gaite vs. Fonacier [GR L-11827, 31 July 1961]; (43) Goldenrod Inc, vs. CA [GR 126812, 24 November 1998]; (44) Guiang vs. CA [GR 125172, 26 June 1998]; (45) J, Schuback & Sons vs. CA [GR 105387, 11 November 1993]; (46) Spouses Ladanga vs. CA [GR L-55999, 24 August 1984]; (47) Legarda Hermanos vs. Saldana [GR L-26578, 28 January 1974]; (48) Levy Hermanos vs. Gervacio [GR 46306, 27 October 1939]; (49) Limketkai Sons Milling vs. CA [GR 118509, 1 December 1995]; (50) Loyola vs. CA [GR 115734, 23 February 2000]; (51) Macondray vs. Eustaquio [GR 43683, 16 July 1937]; (52) Manila Racing Club vs. Manila Jockey Club [GR L-46533, 28 October 1939]; (53) Mapalo vs. Mapalo [GR L-21489 and L-21628, 19 May 1966]; (54) Mate vs. CA [G.R, Nos, 120724-25, 21 May 1998]; (55) Medina vs. Collector of Internal Revenue [GR L-15113, 28 January 1961]; (56) Melliza vs. Iloilo City [GR L-24732, 30 April 1968]; (57) Mendoza vs. Kalaw [GR 16420, 12 October 1921]; (58) Mindanao Academy vs. Yap [GR L-17681, 26 February 1965]; (59) Montilla vs. CA [GR L-47968, 9 May 1988]; (60) National Grains Authority vs. IAC [GR 74470, 8 March 1989]; (61) Navera vs. CA [GR L-56838, 26 April 1990]; (62) Noel vs. CA [GR 59550, 11 January 1995]; (63) Spouses Nonato vs. IAC [GR L-67181, 22 November 1985]; (64) Nool vs. CA [GR 116635, 24 July 1997]; (65) Northern Motors vs. Sapinoso [GR L-28074, 29 May 1970]; (66) Ong vs. CA [GR 97347, 6 July 1999]; (67) Ong vs. Ong [GR L-67888, 8 October 1985]; (68) Pasagui vs. Villablanca [GR L-21998, 10 November 1975]; (69) Paulmitan vs. CA [GR 61584, 25 November 1992]; (70) Philippine Trust Company vs. PNB [GR 16483, 7 December 1921]; (71) Philippine Trust Co. vs. Roldan [GR L-8477, 31 May 1956]; (72) Pichel vs. Alonzo [GR L-36902, 30 January 1982]; (73) Power Commercial and Industrial Corp. vs. CA [GR 119745, 20 June 1997]; (74) Puyat & Sons vs. Arco Amusement [GR 47538, 20 June 1941]; (75) Quijada vs. CA [GR 126444, 4 December 1998]; (76) Quimson vs. Rosete [GR L-2397, 9 August 1950]; (77) Quiroga vs. Parsons Hardware [GR 11491, 23 August 1918]; (78) Radiowealth Finance vs. Palileo [GR 83432, 20 May 1991]; (79) Republic vs. Philippine Development Corp. [GR L-10141, 31 January 1958]; (80) Ridad vs. Filipinas Investment [GR L-39806, 27 January 1983]; (81) Rillo vs. CA [GR 125347, 19 June 1997]; (82) Romero vs. CA [GR 103577, 7 October 1996]; (83) Rubias vs. Batiller [GR L-35702, 29 May 1973]; (84) Sanchez vs. Rigos [GR L-25494, 14 June 1972]; (85) Siy Cong Bieng and Co. vs. Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. [GR 34655, 5 March 1932]; (86) Soriano, et al. vs. Bautista, et al. [GR L-15752, 29 December 1962]; (87) Sta. Ana vs. Hernandez [GR L-16394, 17 December 1966]; (88) Tajanlangit vs. Southern Motors [GR L-10789, 28 May 1957]; (89) Tanedo vs. CA [GR 104482, 22 January 1996]; (90) Torres vs. CA [GR 134559, 9 December 1999]; (91) Toyota Shaw vs. CA [GR 116650, 23 May 1995]; (92) Uy vs. CA [GR 120465, 9 September 1999]; (93) Vallarta vs. CA [GR L-40195, 29 May 1987]; (94) Vasquez vs. CA [GR 83759, 12 July 1991]; (95) Vda. De Gordon vs. CA [GR L-37831, 23 November 1981]; (96) Vda. De Jomoc vs. CA [GR 92871, 2 August 1991]; (97) Vda. De Quiambao vs. Manila Motor Company [GR L-17384, 31 October 1961]; (98) Velasco vs. CA [GR L-31018, 29 June 1973]; (99) Villaflor vs. CA [GR 95694, 9 October 1997]; (100) Villamor vs. CA [GR 97332, 10 October 1991]; (101) Villonco Realty vs. Bormaheco Inc, [GR L-26872, 25 July 1975]; (102) Yu Tek vs. Gonzales [GR 9935, 1 February 1915]; (103) Zayas vs. Luneta Motor Company [GR L-30583, 23 October 1982]

Haystacks for Taxation Law I try to cover the following cases: (1) Abra v. Hernando [GR L-49336, 31 August 1981]; (2) Abra Valley College v. Aquino [GR L-39086, 15 June 1988]; (3) ABS CBN Broadcasting vs. CTA [GR No. L-52306. October 12, 1981.]; (4) American Bible Society v. City of Manila [GR L-9637, 30 April 1957]; (5) American Mail Line vs. Basilan [GR No. L-12647. May 31, 1961.]; (6) Bagatsing vs. Ramirez [GR No. L-41631. December 17, 1976.]; (7) Bishop of Nueva Segovia v. Provincial Board, Ilocos Norte [GR 27588, 31 December 1927]; (8) Cagayan Electric vs. CIR [GR No. L-60126. September 25, 1985.]; (9) CIR v. Algue [GR L-28896, 17 February 1988]; (10) CIR vs. American Rubber Company [GR No. L-19667. November 29, 1966.]; (11) CIR vs. Burroughs Ltd. [GR No. L-66653. June 19, 1986.]; (12) CIR vs. Cebu Portland Cement [GR No. L-29059. December 15, 1987.]; (13) CIR vs. Connel Bros. Co. [GR Nos. L-27752-53. August 30, 1971.]; (14) CIR vs. CA [GR No. 108358. January 20, 1995.]; (15) CIR vs. Fireman’s Fund Insurance [GR No. L-30644. March 9, 1987.]; (16) CIR vs. Gotamco [GR No. L-31092. February 27, 1987.]; (17) CIR vs. Itogon-Suyoc Mines [GR No. L-25299. July 29, 1969.]; (18) CIR vs. Lednicky [GR Nos. L-18169, L-18286, & L-21434. July 31, 1964.]; (19) CIR vs. Lingayen Gulf Electric Power [GR No. L-23771. August 4, 1988.]; (20) CIR vs. Manila Jockey Club [GR No. L-8755. March 23, 1956.]; (21) CIR vs. Mega General Merchandising [GR No. L-69136. September 30, 1988.]; (22) CIR vs. Phoenix Assurance [GR No. L-19727. May 20, 1965.]; (23) CIR vs. Robertson [GR Nos. L-70116-19. August 12, 1986.]; (24) Compania General de Tabacos de Filipinas vs. Manila [GR No. L-16619. June 29, 1963.]; (25) Davao Light and Power vs. Commissioner of Customs [GR Nos. L-28739 & L-28902. March 29, 1972.]; (26) Domingo vs. Garlitos [GR L-18994, 29 June 1963.]; (27) Francia vs. IAC [GR No. L-67649. June 28, 1988.]; (28) Hilado vs. CIR [GR No. L-9408. October 31, 1956.]; (29) Lealda Electric vs. CIR [GR No. L-16428. April 30, 1963.]; (30) Lladoc v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue [GR L-19201, 16 June 1965]; (31) Lutz vs. Araneta [GR No. L-7859. December 22, 1955.]; (32) Luzon Stevedoring vs. CTA [GR No. L-30232. July 29, 1988.]; (33) Misamis Oriental vs. Cagayan Electric [GR No. 45355. January 12, 1990.]; (34) National Development Co. vs. CIR [GR No. L-53961. June 30, 1987.]; (35) Nitafan v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue [GR L-78780, 23 July 1987]; Resolution; (36) Philippine Acetylene vs. CIR [GR No. L-19707. August 17, 1967.]; (37) Philippine Airlines vs. Edu [GR No. L-41383. August 15, 1988.]; (38) Progressive Development Corp. vs. QC [GR No. 36081. April 24, 1989.]; (39) Punsalan v. Municipal Board of Manila [GR L-4817, 26 May 1954]; (40) Reagan vs. CIR [GR No. L-26379. December 27, 1969.]; (41) Republic vs. Mambulao Lumber [GR No. L-17725. February 28, 1962.]; (42) Republic vs. Vda. De Fernandez [GR No. L-9141. September 25, 1956.]; (43) Saldana vs. Iloilo [GR No. L-10470. June 26, 1958.]; (44) Sison v. Ancheta [GR L-59431, 25 July 1984]; (45) SSS vs. Bacolod City [GR No. L-35726. July 21, 1982.]; (46) Surigao Consolidated Mining vs. Collector [GR No. L-14878. December 26, 1963.]; (47) Tanada v. Tuvera [GR L-63915, 24 April 1985]; (48) Villegas v. Hiu Chiong Tsai Pao Ho [GR L-29646, 10 Nov 1978]; (49) Visayan Cebu Terminal vs. CIR [GR Nos. L-19530 & L-19444. February 27, 1965.]; (50) Wonder Mechanical Engineering vs. CTA [GR Nos. L-22805 & L-27858. June 30, 1975.]

Haystacks for Intellectual Property Law try to cover the following cases: (1) Asia Brewery vs. CA, GR 103543, 5 July 1993; (2) Western Equipment vs. Reyes, GR 27897, 2 December 1927; (3) Philips Export BV vs. CA, GR 96161, 21 February 1992; (4) Asari Yoko v. Kee Boc, GR L-14086, 20 January 1961; (5) Sterling Products Vs. Farbenfabriken Bayer, GR L-19906, 30 April 1969; (6) Kabushi Kaisha Isetan vs. lAC, GR 75420, 15 November 1991; (7) Emerald Garment v CA, GR 100098, 29 December 1995; (8) Converse Rubber vs. Universal Rubber, GR L-27906, 8 January 1986; (9) Pagasa Industrial vs. CA, GR L-54158, 31 August 1984; (10) La Chemise Lacoste vs. Fernandez, GR 63796-97, 21 May 1984; (11) Fruit of the Loom vs. CA, GR L-32747, 29 November 1984; (12) Del Monte vs. CA, GR L-78325, 23 January 1990; (13) 246 Corporation v. Daway, GR 157 216, 20 November 2003; (14) Pearl & Dean v. Shoemart, GR 148222, 15 August 2003

Haystacks for Transportation Law try to cover the following cases: (1) Caltex vs. Sulpicio Lines [GR 131166, 30 September 1999]; (2) First Philippine Industrial Corp. vs. CA [GR 125948, 29 December 1998]; (3) Arada vs. CA [GR 98243, 1 July 1992]; (4) Sabena Belgian World Airlines vs. CA [GR 104685, 14 March 1996]; (5) Philippine National Railways [PNR] vs. CA [GR L-55347, 4 October 1985]; (6) Eastern Shipping Lines vs. CA [GR 97412, 12 July 1994]; (7) Metro Port Services vs. CA [GR L-57582, 24 August 1984]; (8) Home Insurance Co. vs. American Steamship Agencies [GR L-25599, 4 April 1968]; (9) National Steel vs. CA [GR 112287, 12 December 1997]; (10) De Villata vs. JS Stanley [GR 8154, 20 December 1915]; (11) US vs. Quinajon [GR 8686, 30 July 1915]; (12) De Guzman vs. CA [GR L-47822, 22 December 1988]; (13) Planters Products vs. CA [GR 101503, 15 September 1993]; (14) Bascos vs. CA [GR 101089, 7 April 1993]; (15) Mendoza vs. PAL [GR L-3678, 29 February 1952]; (16) Coastwise Lighterage Corp. vs. CA [GR 114167, 12 July 1995]; (17) Benedicto vs. IAC [GR 70876, 19 July 1990]; (18) Teja Marketing vs. IAC [GR L-65510, 9 March 1987]; (19) BA Finance vs. CA [GR 98275, 13 November 1992]; (20) Nocum vs. Laguna Tayabas Bus Co. [GR L-23733, 31 October 1969]; (21) Tamayo vs. Aquino, et.al. [GR L-12634 & L-12720, 29 May 1959]; (22) Erezo vs. Jepte [GR L-9605, 30 September 1957]; (23) Zamboanga Transportation Co. vs. CA [GR L-25292, 29 November 1969]; (24) Santos vs. Sibog [GR L-26815, 26 May 1981]; (25) PAL vs. NLRC [GR L-62961, 2 September 1983]; (26) Vasquez vs. CA [GR L-42926, 13 September 1985]; (27) Dangwa Transportation vs. CA [GR 95582, 7 October 1991]; (28) Delsan Transport Lines vs. CA [GR 127897, 15 November 2001]; (29) Loadstar Shipping vs. CA [GR 131621, 28 September 1999]; (30) Metro Manila Transit Corporation vs. CA [GR 104408, 21 June 1993]; (31) Kapalaran Bus vs. Coronado [GR 85331, 25 August 1989]; (32) Trans-Asia Shipping Lines vs. CA [GR 118126, 4 March 1996]; (33) Belgian Overseas Chartering and Shipping vs. Philippine First Insurance Co. Inc. [GR 143133, 5 June 2002]; (34) Yobido vs. CA [GR 113003, 17 October 1997]; (35) National Development Co. vs. CA [GR L-49407, 19 August 1988]; (36) Ganzon vs. CA [GR L-48757, 30 Mary 1988]; (37) Mirasol vs. Robert Dollar Co. [GR 29721, 27 March 1929]; (38) Eastern Shipping Lines vs. IAC [GR L-69044, 29 May 1987]; (39) Kui Pai & Co. vs. Dollar Steamship Line [GR 30019, 2 March 1929]; (40) Compania Maritima vs. Insurance Co. of North America [GR L-18965, 30 October 1964]; (41) Government vs. Inchausti [GR 6957, 14 February 1913]; (42) Samar Mining Co. vs. Nordeutscher Lloyd [GR L-28673, 23 October 1984]; (43) Macam vs. CA [GR 125524, 25 August 1999]; (44) Saludo vs. CA [GR 95536, 23 March 1992]; (45) Delgado Bros. vs. CA [GR L-15654, 29 December 1960]; (46) Eastern Shipping Lines vs. CA [GR 80936, 17 October 1990]; (47) Limpangco Sons vs. Yangco Steamship [GR 10283, 25 July 1916]; (48) G. Martini Ltd. vs. Macondray & Co. [GR 13972, 28 July 1919]; (49) Heirs of de los Santos vs. CA [GR 51165, 21 June 1990]; (50) Compania Maritima vs. CA [GR L-31379, 29 August 1988]; (51) HE Heacock vs. Macondray [GR 16598, 3 October 1921]; (52) St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance vs. Macondray [GR L-27795, 25 March 1976]; (53) Valenzuela Hardwood and Industrial vs. CA [GR 102316, 30 June 1997]; (54) Sweet Line vs. Teves [GR L-37750, 19 May 1978]; (55) Eastern and Australian Steamship vs. Great American Insurance [GR L-37604, 23 October 1981]; (56) Sea-land Service vs. IAC [GR 75118, 31 August 1987]; (57) Aboitiz Shipping vs. CA [GR 89757, 6 August 1990]; (58) Everett Steamship Corp. vs. CA [GR 122494, 8 October 1998]; (59) Shewaram vs. PAL [GR L-20099, 7 July 1966]; (60) Ong Yiu vs. CA [GR L-40597, 29 June 1979]; (61) British Airways vs. CA [GR 121824, 29 January 1998]; (62) PAL vs. CA [GR 92501, 6 March 1992]; (63) Quisumbing vs. CA [GR 50076, 14 September 1990]; (64) PanAm World Airways vs. Rapadas [GR 60673, 19 May 1992]; (65) PAL vs. CA [GR 120262, 17 July 1997]; (66) Baliwag Transit vs. CA [GR 116110, 15 May 1996]; (67) Mecenas vs. CA [GR 88052, 14 December 1989]; (68) PAL vs. CA [GR L-46558, 31 July 1981]; (69) Pilapil vs. CA [GR 52159, 22 December 1989]; (70) Fortune Express vs. CA [GR 119756, 18 March 1999]; (71) Landingin vs. Pangasinan Transportation [GR L-28014-15, 29 May 1970]; (72) California Lines vs. de los Santos [GR L-13254, 30 December 1961]; (73) Estrada vs. Consolacion [GR L-40948, 29 June 1976]; (74) Lara vs. Valencia [GR L-9907, 30 June 1958]; (75) Bayasen vs. CA [GR L-25785, 26 February 1981]; (76) Cervantes vs. CA [GR 125138, 2 March 1999]; (77) De Gillaco vs. Manila Railroad Co. [GR L-8034, 18 November 1955]; (78) Maranan vs. Perez [GR L-2272, 26 June 1967]; (79) Lasam vs. Smith [GR 19495, 2 February 1924]; (80) Sweet Lines vs. CA [GR L-46340, 28 April 1983]; (81) Magboo vs. Bernardo [GR L-16790, 30 April 1963]; (82) Isaac vs. AL Ammen Transportation [GR L-9671, 23 August 1957]; (83) Panay Autobus vs. Pastor [GR 47933, 29 July 1942]; (84) Del Prado vs. Meralco [GR 29462, 7 March 1929]; (85) Cangco vs. Manila Railroad [GR 12191, 14 October 1918]; (86) De Guia vs. Manila Electric Railroad & Light Co. [GR 14335, 28 January 1920]; (87) Calalas vs. CA [GR 122039, 31 May 2000]; (88) Light Rail Transit Authority vs. Navidad [GR 145804, 6 February 2003]; (89) La Mallorca vs. CA [GR L-20761, 27 July 1966]; (90) Aboitiz Shipping Corp. vs. CA [GR 84458, 6 November 1989]; (91) Bachelor Express vs. CA [GR 85691, 31 July 1990]; (92) Bacarro vs. Castano [GR L-34597, 5 November 1982]; (93) Laguna Tayabas Bus vs. Tiongson [GR L-22143, 30 April 1966]; (94) Sulpicio Lines vs. CA [GR 113578, 14 July 1995]; (95) Fisher vs. Yangco Steamship [GR 8085, 5 November 1914]; (96) Fisher vs. Yangco Steamship [GR 8095, 31 March 1915]; (97) Maritime Co. of the Philippines vs. CA [GR 47004, 8 March 1989]; (98) Gatchalian vs. Delim [GR 56487, 21 October 1991]; (99) American Home Assurance vs. CA [GR 94149, 5 May 1992]; (100) Eastern Shipping Lines vs. Margarine-Verkaufs-Union GmbH [GR L-31087, 27 September 1979]; (101) Magellan Manufacturing Marketing vs. CA [GR 95529, 22 August 1991]; (102) Reyma Brokerage vs. Philippine Home Assurance Corp. [GR 93464, 7 October 1991]; (103) Keng Hua Paper Products vs. CA [GR 116863, 12 February 1998]; (104) Ysmael vs. Barretto [GR 28028, 25 November 1927]; (105) Maersk Line vs. CA [GR 94761, 17 May 1993]; (106) New Zealand Insurance Co. vs. IAC [GR L-66596, 28 August 1984]; (107) Mariano Uy Chaco Sons & Co. vs. Admiral Line [GR 22134, 17 October 1924]; (108) Standard Vacuum Oil Co. vs. Luzon Stevedoring Co. [GR L-5203, 18 April 1956]; (109) Tan Chiong Sian vs. Inchausti [GR 6092, 8 March 1912]; (110) New Zealand Insurance vs. Chua Joy [GR L-7311, 30 September 1955]; (111) E. Razon vs, CA [GR L-50242, 21 May 1988]; (112) Pernito Arrastre Services vs. Mendoza [GR L-53492, 29 December 1986]; (113) Tan Pho vs. Dalamal [GR 45598, 26 April 1939]; (114) Baer Senior & Co. vs. La Compania Maritima [GR 1963, 30 April 1906]; (115) Lopez vs. Duruelo [GR 29166, 22 October 1928]; (116) Philippine Refining v. Jarque [GR 41506, 25 March 1935]; (117) McMicking vs. El Banco Espanol-Filipino [GR 5029, 1 April 1909]; (118) Ivancich vs. Odlin [GR 924, 1 May 1902]; (119) Heath vs. Steamer San Nicolas [GR L-3066, 25 February 1907]; (120) Manila Steamship vs. Insa Abdulhaman [GR L-9534, 29 September 1956]; (121) Chua Yek Hong vs. IAC [GR L-74811, 30 September 1988]; (122) Commissioner vs. US Lines [GR L-16850, 30 May 1962]; (123) Madrigal Shipping vs. Ogilve [GR L-8431, 30 October 1958]; (124) Garcia vs. Ruiz [GR 923, 16 January 1903]; (125) Yaptico vs. Anderson [GR 9366, 1 August 1916]; (126) Yu Con vs. Ipil [GR 10195, 29 December 1916]; (127) US vs. Steamship “Islas Filipinas” [GR 8746, 30 October 1914]; (128) Ohta Development Co. vs. Steamship Pompey [GR 24658, 31 March 1926]; (129) Triton Insurance vs. Jose [GR 10381 and 10714, 14 January 1916]; (130) USA vs. Steamship Rubi [GR 9235, 17 November 1915]; (131) International Harvester Co. in Russia vs. Hamburg-American Line [GR 11515, 29 July 1918]; (132) Compagnie Franco-Indochinoise vs. Deutsch Australische Dampschiffs Gesselschaft [GR 11169, 31 March 1917]; (133) Guzman vs. William X [GR L-3649, 24 October 1907]; (134) US vs. Bacho [GR L-4091, 25 March 1908]; (135) Vir-Jen Shipping and Marine Services, NLRC [GR L-58011-12, 20 July 1982]; (136) Wallem Phil. Shipping vs. Minister of Labor [GR L-50734-37, 20 February 1981]; (137) Abueg vs. San Diego [CA-773-775, 17 December 1946]; (138) Murillo vs. Mendoza [GR 46020, 8 December 1938]; (139) Macondray vs. Delgado Bros. [GR L-13118, 28 April 1960]; (140) Bryan vs. Eastern & Australian SS [GR 9403, 4 November 1914]; (141) Puromines Inc. vs. CA [GR 91228, 22 March 1993]; (142) Litonjua Shipping vs. National Seamen Board [GR 51910, 10 August 1989]; (143) Maritime Agencies & Services vs. CA [GR 77638, 12 July 1990]; (144) Ouano vs. CA [GR 95900, 23 July 1992]; (145) NFA vs. CA [GR 96453, 4 August 1999]; (146) Market Developers vs. IAC [GR 74978, 8 September 1989]; (147) Marimperio Compania Naviera vs. CA [GR L-40234, 14 December 1987]; (148) O’Farrel vs. Meralco [GR 31222, 29 October 1929]; (149) Overseas Factors Inc. vs. South Sea Shipping [GR L-12138, 27 February 1962]; (150) Phoenix Assurance Co. Ltd. vs. US Lines [GR L-24033, 22 February 1968]; (151) Telengtan Bros. & Sons. Vs. CA [GR 110581, 21 September 1994]; (152) De la Riva vs. Lizarraga Hermanos [GR L-2464, 7 January 1907]; (153) Philippine Home Assurance vs. CA [GR 106999, 20 June 1996]; (154) A. Magsaysay Inc. vs. Agan [GR L-6393, 31 January 1955]; (155) Austria vs. CA [GR 133323, 9 March 2000]; (156) Smith Bell vs. CA [GR 56294, 20 May 1991]; (157) Manila vs. Atlantic Gulf and Pacific Co. [GR 4510, 19 December 1908]; (158) Marine Trading vs. Government [GR 13422, 8 November 1918]; (159) A. Urrutia & Co. vs. Baco River Plantation [GR 7675, 25 March 1913]; (160) Versoza vs. Lim [GR 20145, 15 November 1923]; (160) Government vs. Philippine Steamship Co. [GR 18957, 16 January 1923]; (161) Picart vs. Smith [GR L-12219, 15 March 1918]; (162) US vs. Smith Bell [GR 1876, 30 September 1905]; (163) Philippine Shipping Co. vs. Vergara [GR 1600, 1 June 1906]; (164) Chin Guan vs. Compania Maritima [GR 45070, 28 November 1938]; (165) Manila Railroad vs. Macondray [GR L-12475, 21 March 1918]; (166) Standard Oil Co. of New York vs. Lopez Castelo [GR 13695, 18 October 1921]; (167) Jarque vs. Smith Bell [GR 32986, 11 November 1930]; (168) Taxicab Operators v. The Board of Transportation [GR L-59234, 30 September 1982]; (169) Napocor vs. CA [GR 113103, 13 June 1997]; (170) GMCR vs. Bell Telecoms [GR 126496, 30 April 1997]; (171) Maceda vs. ERB [GR 95203-05, 18 December 1990]; (172) Lagman vs. Manila [GR L-23305, 30 June 1966]; (173) Philippine Global Communications vs. Relova [GR L-52819, 2 October 1980]; (174) Philippine Global vs. Relova [GR L-60548, 10 November 1986]; (175) PLDT vs. NTC [GR 88404, 18 October 1990]; (176) RCPI vs. Rodriguez [GR 83768, 28 February 1990]; (177) Telefast Communications vs. Castro [GR 73867, 29 February 1988]; (178) RCPI vs. CA [GR 79578, 13 March 1991]; (179) Zulueta vs. Pan American World Airways [GR L-28589, 8 January 1973]; Res.; (180) Lopez vs. Pan American World Airways [GR L-22415, 30 March 1966]; (181) Pan American World Airways vs. IAC [GR L-70462, 11 August 1988]; (182) Luna vs. CA [GR 100374-75, 27 November 1992]; (183) Santos vs. Northwest Orient Airlines [GR 101538, 23 June 1992]; (184) Tan vs. Northwestern Airlines [GR 135802, 3 March 2000]; (185) American Airlines vs. CA [GR 116044-45, 9 March 2000]; (186) Yu Eng Cho vs. Pan American World Airways [GR 123560, 27 March 2000]; (187) Rizal Surety & Insurance vs. Macondray & Co. [GR L-24064, 29 February 1968]; (188) The American Insurance Co. vs. Compania Maritima [GR L-24515, 18 November 1967]; (189) Mitsui vs. CA [GR 119571, 11 March 1998]; (190) Mayer Steel Pipe vs. CA [GR 124050, 19 June 1997]; (191) Barrios vs. Go Thong [GR L-17192, 30 March 1963]; (192) Wallace vs. Pujalte Co. [GR 10019, 29 March 1916]; (193) Atlantic Gulf & Pacific Co. vs. Uchida Kisen Kaisha [GR 15871, 7 November 1921]; (194) Erlanger & Galinger vs. Swedish East Asiatic [GR 10051, 9 March 1916]; (195) Pestano vs. Sumayang [GR 139875, 4 December 2000]

Haystacks for Telecommunication Law try to cover the following cases: (1) GMCR vs. Bell Telecommunication Philippines (BellTel), GR 126496, 30 April 1997; (2) PLDT vs. NTC, GR 88404, 18 October 1990; (3) Republic vs. Meralco, GR 141314, 15 November 2002; (4) Smart Communications vs. NTC, GR 151908, 12 August 2003

Haystacks for Taxation Law II try to cover the following cases: (1) Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Ayala Securities Corp. (GR L-29485, 21 November 1980); (2) Collector of Internal Revenue vs. Benipayo (GR L-13656, 31 January 1962); (3) Butuan Sawmill vs. Court of Tax Appeals (GR L-20601, 28 February 1966); (4) CIR vs. Phoenix Assurance [GR L-19727. 20 May 1965.]; (5) Nava vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (GR L-19470, 30 January 1965); (6) Tuason & Legarda Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (GR L-18552, 30 September 1965); (7) Roman Catholic Archbishop of Cebu vs. Collector of Internal Revenue (GR L-16683, 31 January 1962); (8) Filipinas Investment & Finance Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (GR L-23501, 16, May 1967); (9) Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Isabela Cultural Corporation (GR 135210, 11 July 2001); (10) Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Union Shipping Corporation (GR 66160, 21 May 1990); (11) Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Philippine American Life Insurance Co. (GR 105208, 29 May 1995); (12) ACCRA Investments Corporation vs. Court of Appeals (GR 96322, 20 December 1991); (13) Koppel (Phils.) Inc. vs. Collector of Internal Revenue (GR L-10550, 19 September 1961); (14) Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Victorias Milling Co. (GR L-24108, 3 January 1968); (15) Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Concepcion (GR L-23912, 15 March 1968); (16) Philippine Bank of Communications vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (GR 112024, 28 January 1999); (17) Ungab vs. Cusi Jr. (GR L-41919-25, 30 May 1980); (18) Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Court of Appeals (GR 119322, 4 June 1996)

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s